St. Augustine

Good morning.

Yesterday a bishop told a weeping mother her son would never perish. Today, the Church keeps that son's memorial as a Doctor of the Church.

On buying and selling honestly

St. Augustine tells a small story that St. Thomas Aquinas later uses to make a much larger point. A jester once said, in front of a crowd, "you wish to buy for a song and to sell at a premium" — and everyone laughed, because everyone recognized the instinct. Aquinas doesn't pretend the instinct isn't universal. He simply refuses to let universal mean acceptable: "this jester, either by looking into himself or by his experience of others, thought that all men are inclined to wish to buy for a song and sell at a premium. But since in reality this is wicked, it is in every man's power to acquire that justice whereby he may resist and overcome this inclination."

From there Aquinas builds his teaching on just price (Summa Theologiae II-II, Q. 77, Art. 1). His starting principle: "buying and selling seem to be established for the common advantage of both parties, one of whom requires that which belongs to the other, and vice versa... Now whatever is established for the common advantage, should not be more of a burden to one party than to another." His conclusion follows directly: "to sell a thing for more than its worth, or to buy it for less than its worth, is in itself unjust and unlawful." Not merely bad manners. Unjust.

He isn't naive about circumstance — he allows that a price can reasonably reflect real loss to a seller or real value to a buyer in a specific situation, without that becoming license for deception. What he closes the door on entirely is fraud dressed up as a deal: "it is altogether sinful to have recourse to deceit in order to sell a thing for more than its just price, because this is to deceive one's neighbor so as to injure him."

A market built on that standard doesn't ask "what can I get away with." It asks whether both sides of the transaction actually gained something real. That's not a medieval sentiment retired by modern finance — it's the same question underneath every disclosure requirement, every fraud statute, every honest research report. Augustine noticed the impulse first. Aquinas built the discipline for resisting it.

Memorial of Saint Augustine, Bishop and Doctor of the Church

The same warning as yesterday, one day further into the week. Yesterday's servant failed by presuming the delay meant he could stop watching. Today's foolish virgins fail by assuming there'd be time to prepare once the moment actually arrived — they go to buy oil only after the cry goes up, and the door closes while they're still at the market. Augustine spent years assuming there'd be time later. When the moment came in Milan, the readiness was already required, not still being assembled.

bible.usccb.org/bible/readings/082826.cfm →

Thursday's close · SPY $771.10, +0.66% · system ACTIVE

A strong session. SPY closed up 0.66%, and the system triggered three breakouts — the widest single day this week. CrowdStrike (CRWD) broke its 52-week pivot on a 153% volume surge, Okta (OKTA) broke out on a 434% surge, and Prenetics (PRE) broke out again — its third breakout this week — on 354% volume. Twenty-seven names cleared every gate in all. CRWD leads the actionable list at score 100, RS 93, $227.96.

Enoch Capital  ·  Chart  ·  Research & Due Diligence

→ Zero management fee. 20% performance only. 10% of that tithed.

Enoch Capital LLC  ·  2121 S. Broadway, #511, Denver CO 80210
Catholic Daily is an educational publication. It is not investment advice. References to markets, specific securities, or economic conditions are illustrative only and do not constitute recommendations to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Enoch Capital LLC operates under the Publisher's Exemption from the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (Lowe v. SEC, 472 U.S. 181, 1985). Nothing on this site constitutes the rendering of personalized investment advice. Enoch Capital LLC is not a registered investment adviser.